logo

Manchester United Manager Odds: 23 Candidates to Succeed Michael Carrick

Michael Carrick seemed to bring hope when he took over as interim manager for Manchester United in January, following a turbulent period under Ruben Amorim. The team showed significant improvement and secured a Champions League spot, prompting the club to appoint him permanently. Yet, the start of the 2026/27 season has seen a sharp decline in results.

After just one win in six Premier League games this season, questions arise about Carrick's ability to lead. Notable setbacks include a 1-0 home loss to a 10-man Manchester City, a shocking Carabao Cup defeat to Brighton after leading 2-0 at halftime—marking the first time in 50 years United lost a home match from such a position—and dropping points late against Tottenham, who also played with ten men. Most recently, a 2-0 defeat by Atletico Madrid led defender Lisandro Martinez to criticize the club's lack of investment.

Pressure mounts on Carrick as speculation grows around potential replacements. SkyBet has listed 23 managers who could take charge if United decides to part ways with their current boss.

Long Shots and High Odds

  • Lionel Scaloni (Argentina) - 80/1
  • Ange Postecoglou (Al-Nassr) - 80/1
  • David Moyes (Everton) - 80/1
  • Roberto Mancini (Italy) - 66/1
  • Ralf Rangnick (Austria) - 66/1
  • Diego Simeone (Atletico Madrid) - 50/1
  • Daniel Farke (Leeds United) - 50/1
  • Brendan Rodgers (Al Qadsiah) - 50/1
  • Sebastian Hoeness (VfB Stuttgart) - 50/1

Some names like David Moyes seem unlikely to return given his past struggles despite early promise. Ralf Rangnick might avoid a second spell after criticizing the club hierarchy during his interim tenure. Diego Simeone'sDaniel Farke and Brendan Rodgers represent risks due to their lack of experience managing clubs of United's stature.

Mid-range Contenders

  • Luis Enrique (PSG) - 33/1
  • Ole Gunnar Solskjaer (Unattached) - 25/1
  • Mauricio Pochettino (USA) - 25/1
  • Roberto Martinez (Unattached) - 22/1
  • Darren Fletcher (Man Utd U18s) - 20/1
  • Carlo Ancelotti (Brazil) - 20/1
  • Gareth Southgate (Unattached) - 14/1

Luis Enrique brings a track record of Champions League success, though his current PSG job comes with heavy financial backing. Ole Gunnar Solskjaer remains a fan favourite but is currently unattached. Mauricio Pochettino is admired for his tactical skills, while Roberto Martinez offers Premier League experience but little excitement. Darren Fletcher, coaching United’s youth, would be a stop-gap option. Carlo Ancelotti and Gareth Southgate are free agents with strong reputations.

Top Picks and Favourites

  • Unai Emery (Aston Villa) - 14/1
  • Thomas Tuchel (England) - 14/1
  • Kieran McKenna (Unattached) - 10/1
  • Julian Nagelsmann (Unattached) - 13/2
  • Antonio Conte (Napoli) - 5/1
  • Fabian Hurzeler (Brighton & Hove Albion) - 5/1
  • Eddie Howe (Unattached) - 2/1

Unai Emery has rebuilt his reputation with Aston Villa despite past Arsenal struggles. Thomas Tuchel remains a strong candidate but likely to stay with England until Euro 2028. Kieran McKenna, former United assistant, could return in some capacity. Julian Nagelsmann, fresh off Germany’s disappointing World Cup, is a youthful choice with Bundesliga success. Antonio Conte brings instant impact history, while young Fabian Hurzeler impresses with Brighton. The clear favourite is Eddie Howe, recently stepping down at Newcastle and expected to quickly return to management.

These odds reflect the ongoing uncertainty at Old Trafford as Manchester United seeks stability and success once again.

Odds Source: SkyBet, as of 14 October 2026.

Related Articles