Could Man City's Financial Fair Play Troubles Spark New Super League Debate? Danny Mills Cautions Using LIV Golf as an Example
Manchester City's FFP Case and the Possibility of a Super League Revival
Manchester City’s ongoing Financial Fair Play (FFP) investigation has brought spending rules back into focus. This situation raises the question: could it reignite discussions about a European Super League? Former City defender Danny Mills shared his views with GOAL, highlighting why such a league still faces major challenges. He also pointed to the example of LIV Golf as a cautionary tale for football clubs or governing bodies tempted to break away from existing structures.
The Fallout from the Original Super League Proposal
In early 2021, twelve major clubs planned to create their own competition, aiming to expand eventually to 20 teams. The English "Big Six" — including Manchester City, Liverpool, Manchester United, Chelsea, Arsenal, and Tottenham — were all involved. Fans reacted strongly against the idea, forcing the project to collapse. Still, some clubs like Real Madrid and Juventus have not completely abandoned the concept.
A big hurdle for any breakaway league is that players participating would lose eligibility for international tournaments under UEFA and FIFA. That would complicate transfers, although such a league would likely drop FFP and salary cap rules, giving wealthy clubs freedom to spend. Currently, City face 114 FFP-related charges, with severe penalties possible.
Why Players Would Resist Leaving Existing Competitions
Mills explained the difficulty in leaving established football bodies: "To play international football, FIFA must approve your competition. If they don’t approve your Super League, players can’t play for their countries." He emphasized the prestige tied to international trophies and national recognition. Winning the World Cup or Euros cements a player’s legacy far beyond club success. "You get knighthoods," Mills added, showing how much weight these honors carry.
He doubts a Super League would ever gain long-term traction. "Saudi Arabia tried it, China tried before — neither worked. Players will always want to compete internationally."
LIV Golf Shows Independent Leagues Face Major Obstacles
Other sports have seen breakaway leagues, like LIV Golf, which attracted top players with big contracts and fresh formats. Yet, the venture is now in bankruptcy talks, seeking new partners and funding. Mills sees parallels with a potential Super League attempt.
"How has LIV Golf gone? Not well. They found a short-term fix that collapsed because the sport lost its appeal," Mills said. "Sport thrives on risk and fair competition. Without relegation or consequences, games become dull."
He highlighted how competitive structures like promotion and relegation keep fans engaged. In leagues without such stakes, teams lose motivation mid-season, hurting quality and interest. "If a Super League lacks jeopardy, people won’t watch," Mills insisted.
Man City Awaiting FFP Sanctions Amid Uncertainty
The final outcome for Manchester City remains unclear as they appeal against the initial FFP verdicts. English football faces uncertainty around possible expulsions, point deductions, or transfer bans. Questions linger over how current league standings and titles might be affected if harsh penalties are imposed. City’s upcoming matches, including their Premier League fixture on October 17, 2026, will unfold under this cloud.
- Upcoming Match: Manchester City vs. Ipswich Town
- Competition: Premier League
- Date & Time: 17 October 2026, 17:00
