Michael Carrick or Eddie Howe: Who Should Lead Manchester United?
As rumors swirl about a possible managerial change at Old Trafford, the question arises: should Manchester United continue with Michael Carrick or bring in Eddie Howe? Paul Parker, a former Premier League champion with United, shared his thoughts with GOAL on which coach might be better suited to steer the club forward amid this uncertainty.
Carrick’s Impact as Interim Boss
When Michael Carrick took over mid-January, replacing caretaker Darren Fletcher after Ruben Amorim's departure, fans hoped the club had found the right leader. Carrick, who enjoyed success at United as a player, began with strong results, including a derby victory over Manchester City and an away win at Arsenal, the season’s eventual champions.
Contract Signed but Performance Worries
Despite securing a third-place finish last season, United did not make significant signings over the summer, leaving some gaps in their squad. This season has been challenging; they've managed just two wins in nine games across all competitions and remain without a victory in their last five matches. With pressure mounting, there are whispers that the club may soon consider a managerial change.
Howe’s Availability and Suitability
Eddie Howe, who left Newcastle United in July after nearly five years, is being linked as a potential successor. However, the club’s board knows he might not stay available for long. The question is whether Howe would want to take on a role where spending is limited and control over staff is uncertain.
Paul Parker’s Take on the Situation
“I still think you’d stay with Carrick,” Parker said. “Eddie Howe went through tough times with his previous employers. Would he want to walk into something very similar at United? He wouldn’t have the freedom to spend what he wants or bring in his own team.”
“The current environment at United isn’t great. It affects everything, from the dressing room to operations. It’s not a place for someone ambitious because winning the league here feels impossible right now.”
“United struggles with buying and selling players effectively. Many players seem content to stay put, making it hard to refresh the squad.”
“Eddie’s next job needs to be the right one. He’ll want to work with people who share his ambition. At United, the expectation is always to compete for the title, but the reality doesn’t match that.”
“People talked about United being contenders this season and last, but it didn’t happen. Many ignored the real situation behind the scenes.”
Current Challenges Facing Manchester United
The club hasn’t won the Premier League since Sir Alex Ferguson retired in 2013. They’re far from having their issues sorted, both on and off the pitch. Eliminated early from the Carabao Cup and sitting 13th in the league after six matches with only six points, United face a tough path back to the top.
Their recent 2-0 loss to Atletico Madrid in the Champions League was marred by a red card for Leny Yoro and a sharp post-match critique from Lisandro Martinez. As Carrick holds onto his position, United prepares to face Leeds at Elland Road, a crucial test ahead.
Upcoming Match
- Date: 18 Oct 2026
- Time: 16:00
- Opponent: Leeds United
- Competition: Premier League
